With rapidly rising COVID-19 cases and the nation entering its 4th stage of ‘unlocking’, learning and schooling are being encouraged through digital forms of education. The new National Education Policy (NEP) too encourages leveraging technology and innovation in teaching. In such a scenario, the questions of access and equity have become key concerns with millions of children, particularly girls being at risk of dropping out of schools due to the digital divide.
At the same time, according to research from UNESCO, an estimated 2.7 million teachers in India have been impacted by the pandemic-related school closures and require serious training in adapting to new styles of teaching. With teachers struggling to adapt to the new method of teaching, the quality of education is taking a hit as well.
This Teacher’s Day, YKA hosted a Twitter Chat with 4 education experts and 4 teachers to initiate a conversation on the issues teachers themselves are facing, and what and where are the gaps that need to be filled to build stronger, technologically driven institutions for better education.
Today on #TeachersDay, join us for a critical conversation as @shaheenmistri, @ParagReads, @kishanganjazad1, and @naliniravi9 discuss the impact of digital education on teachers during #COVID-19! Tweet to us your questions using #BackToSchool pic.twitter.com/qUrHVfrTvC
— Youth Ki Awaaz (@YouthKiAwaaz) September 5, 2020
We’re also going to be joined by four teachers on the #BackToSchool chat this #TeachersDay: Ankur Tripathi Vimukt, Shristi Tiwari, Imran Khan and Vivek Verma, who will speak about the challenges they faced due to the pandemic! pic.twitter.com/J4e7PjZSyM
— Youth Ki Awaaz (@YouthKiAwaaz) September 5, 2020
1. Access, Training, and Care – the three critical needs of teachers
Speaking on the ways digital inequities can be bridged in government schools, Shaheen Mistri, CEO of Teach For India, highlighted the gaps in accessing digital devices, among students. She further said that through a blended-learning approach, this gap can be filled and children can continue to experience the joy of learning even during these difficult times.
Our Fellows are being their most creative selves for learning to take place. Uploading videos to YouTube, xeroxing workbooks, lesson plans through Whatsapp, assigning tasks on texts, conducting classes via telephone calls are some examples of the solutions they’ve employed.(3/3)
— Teach For India (@TeachForIndia) September 5, 2020
In light of the NEP, she emphasized the urgent need to train teachers in online teaching and to enable them with the skills required to provide safe spaces online, a role traditionally played by physical schools.
She also suggested a 3-step model to ensure that needs of both teachers and students are addressed during this challenging time that results in an education system that is better equipped and attuned to the needs of its most important stakeholders, the students.
Step 1 is access. We have to fix the access problem. Without access to a device, kids cannot learn. And the digital divide is going to cause greater inequity. (1/3)#BackToSchool https://t.co/lL0UxjCJ05
— Shaheen Mistri (@shaheenmistri) September 5, 2020
Step 2 is supporting teachers to pivot to online teaching. Virtual teaching won't work if we do what we did in a physical classroom. It's a huge reorientation for our teachers. (2/3)#BackToSchool https://t.co/lL0UxjCJ05
— Shaheen Mistri (@shaheenmistri) September 5, 2020
Step 3 is caring deeply for our kids at this time. Finding ways to check in with them, keep them safe, look after their well-being while keeping the bar high on their learning (3/3)#BackToSchool https://t.co/lL0UxjCJ05
— Shaheen Mistri (@shaheenmistri) September 5, 2020
Teachers from the panel shared their personal experiences of being unable to reach their students and losing their jobs as well – a narrative that hasn’t been receiving the media attention it deserves. But solving this issue is a critical step towards building better institutions and getting children back to school.
कोरोना महामारी के दौरान सुदूर गांव में आवागमन के साधन सुलभता से उपलब्ध नहीं हो सकें जिस कारण लोगों तक आसानी से पहुँच पाना मुश्किल भरा रहा।जिस कारण लोगों तक अन्य जरूरी सुविधाएं व जानकारी तत्काल रूप से उपलब्ध करा पाने में कठिनाई महसूस हुई। #BackToSchool
— Ankur Tripathi (@ankur_vimukt) September 5, 2020
कोरोना महामारी ने मुझे बहुत प्रभावित किया है और इसी प्रभाव के चलते मुझे अपनी नौकरी से हाथ धोना पड़ा क्योंकि इसके अलावा मेरे पास कोई विकल्प ही नहीं था।
— Shirsti Tiwari (@shirsti_tiwari) September 5, 2020
2. Meaningful online interventions can be created with the right training and support
Physical spaces such as libraries have played a crucial role in sparking and maintaining the interest of children in schools. Swaha Sahoo, Head, Parag Initiative, Tata Trusts, joined the conversation to discuss the challenges and solutions to providing this space online.
Teachers play a crucial role in enabling this environment. Children take books home & read to siblings & parents. We have seen parents engage with libraries & encourage children to read. This has strengthened their relationship with the school (3/3) #BackToSchool
— ParagReads (@ParagReads) September 5, 2020
Before teachers can provide education online, they themselves need access to digital devices. Swaha highlighted how access to such devices is yet to become a reality for many teachers in India’s most backward areas and as a result, teaching has come to a standstill. But with efforts underway to provide teachers and students with access, she provided a concrete roadmap that teachers can take to make online engagements with students more meaningful.
Understand your audience – Before offering online content, it is important to understand your audience. This includes their access to technology and the online course material, ability to absorb content, and willingness to participate in a new form of learning (1/4)
— ParagReads (@ParagReads) September 5, 2020
Know the content well- One of the first things to do in preparation for online training is map out the content that you plan to offer and understand what content lends itself to an online format (2/4)
— ParagReads (@ParagReads) September 5, 2020
Design for Online – The same session design often will not work online. Tweak it as needed and make online sessions as collaborative and interactive as possible (3/4)
— ParagReads (@ParagReads) September 5, 2020
Support and Communication – This most important as many teachers are navigating online spaces and virtual discussions for the first time. Support this process through mentoring and continuous communication (4/4)
— ParagReads (@ParagReads) September 5, 2020
In addition to making interactions more meaningful, teachers and students require additional psycho-social support. The anxiety and fear brought on by the pandemic coupled with job insecurity, has had a major impact on the mental health of teachers. Teachers from the panel shared some of these concerns.
कोविड काल मानसिक रूप से चिंतित रहने का समय रहा है। परन्तु इस दौरान मैंने कभी भी इसे अपने ऊपर हावी नहीं होने दिया। पूर्ण दिशा निर्देश का पालन करते हुए लोगों के मध्य मैं डटा रहा और खड़ा रहा। उस दौरान कई मुश्किलों का भी सामना करना पड़ा जैसे आवश्यक संशाधन का अभाव
— Ankur Tripathi (@ankur_vimukt) September 5, 2020
कोरोना ने लगभग सभी को मानसिक रूप से कुछ न कुछ परेशान किया ही है।जब लाकडाउन लगा तो ये लगा कि यह जल्द ही समाप्त हो जाएगा लेकिन यह बढ़ता रहा।घरों में लगातार रहने के कारण व्यवहार में चिड़चिड़ापन आ गया।फिर अनलॉक के बाद मानसिक रूप से संक्रमित होने का भय बना रहता है।
— VIVEK VERMA (@VIVEK121292) September 5, 2020
कोविड ने हम सभी को सीधे तौर पर प्रभावित किया है मानसिक प्रभाव तो है ही क्योंकि हम जिस कार्यक्षेत्र में है वहां कागजों से ज्यादा असल मेहनत की जरूरत होती है लेकिन अनिश्चित भय की वजह से अब सहजता से सम्भव नहीं हो पा रहा है।
— Shirsti Tiwari (@shirsti_tiwari) September 5, 2020
3. Training in creating safe spaces online is the need of the hour to ensure girls don’t drop out
Discussing the need to adopt a gendered lens when re-integrating children into the education system, Yuman Hussain, Executive Director, Azad India Foundation (AIF), added her perspective on pandemic’s impact on the efforts of civil society organizations.
Citing a National Sample Survey report, she highlighted how only 16% of girls in rural areas have access to the internet. With limited access to the internet, girls in rural areas are experiencing a greater learning loss and a higher risk of dropping out of school.
The need of the hour is that teachers and students both should have access to internet and digital tools so that their education can continue otherwise we will see huge number of children especially girls leaving schools. #BackToSchool
— AzadIndiaFoundation (@kishanganjazad1) September 5, 2020
Girls in Bihar are facing an even greater challenge to education as they battle both the pandemic and floods. With little support from the government, teachers are rising to the occasion on their own volition.
Safety concerns for girls participating on online platforms has also led to many parents preventing their daughters from pursuing digital education. Teachers from the panel discussed how the pandemic is disproportionately affecting girls.
ऑनलाइन शिक्षण में फोन नम्बर की जरूरत होती है।बहुत सारे अभिभावक छात्रा का नम्बर वायरल होने के डर से नम्बर देने में कतराते हैं।यद्यपि एक जिम्मेदार ग्रुप में ऐसा होने की संभावना नगण्य है लेकिन पूर्वाग्रह के कारण वे ऐसा सोचते हैं।जिससे उनकी शिक्षा में बाधा आती है।
— VIVEK VERMA (@VIVEK121292) September 5, 2020
कोविड ने लड़कियों की शिक्षा को पूरी तरह से प्रभावित किया है। लड़कियों को लड़कों की अपेक्षा वो सभी सुविधाएं आज भी ग्रामीण क्षेत्रों में नहीं दी जाती जो कि उनके लिए जरूरी है, लड़कियों को अत्यधिक घरेलू काम काज कराये जाने पर ध्यान दिया जाता। #BackToSchool
— Ankur Tripathi (@ankur_vimukt) September 5, 2020
कोविड के दौरान तो है ही कोविड के बाद भी लड़कियों की शिक्षा बढ़े स्तर पर बाधित होगी। ग्रामीण क्षेत्रों में उनके पास ना एंड्रॉयडसेट हैं और यदि हैं तब मेल टीचर या साथी छात्रों से सम्पर्क रखने की इजाज़त ही उन्हें नहीं मिली है।डिजिटल शिक्षा तक उनका पहुंचना अब वाक़ई मुश्किल है।
— Shirsti Tiwari (@shirsti_tiwari) September 5, 2020
4. Effective policy-formulation keeping ground-realities and the needs of both teachers and students are critical to ensure continued education
Further enriching the conversation with her experiences from on-ground reporting, Nalini Ravichandran, an independent journalist, commented on government efforts and on-ground realities.
There have been digital initiatives taken by the MHRD including SWAYAM, Virtual Labs, ARPIT programme, E-Yantra etc. along with the digital training of 2 lakh plus teachers by the CBSE during the pandemic. (1/4)#BackToSchool
— Nalini Ravichandran (@naliniravi9) September 5, 2020
But a report of UNESCO in May 2020 stated that 2.7 million teachers in India are digitally untrained. Teachers have not been spared by the digital divide with only 25% Indian households having internet facilities which drops to 15% in rural areas. (2/4)#BackToSchool
— Nalini Ravichandran (@naliniravi9) September 5, 2020
She summed up how urban India experienced a tech boom while the poor were left out, with a quote from a government school teacher in Bastar whom she interviewed:
“When we don’t have proper electricity, device or internet, what purpose do free digital resources serve? How are we expected to take virtual classes when a decent network for a video call lasts hardly a few minutes.” (4/4)#BackToSchool
— Nalini Ravichandran (@naliniravi9) September 5, 2020
With teachers being unable to contact and map the progress of their students, anganwadi workers, and even frontline workers and psychologists have been stepping in to provide well-being support to children in rural areas.
As the pandemic is resulting in many teachers either losing their jobs or facing massive pay-cuts, she called upon the government to recognize teachers as essential workers and devise effective policies to train and equip them with digital resources.
Teachers should not lose their jobs on the grounds of digital ineptitude instead the govt. should bring effective policies to train them and provide access. (4/6)#BackToSchool
— Nalini Ravichandran (@naliniravi9) September 5, 2020
If admissions don’t happen in edu institutions, we have seen that teachers don’t get paid. Govt. must ensure that students don’t drop out. This can be done if it creates directives for private schools to get fees in installments and loans at minimal interest. (5/6)#BackToSchool
— Nalini Ravichandran (@naliniravi9) September 5, 2020
Edu policy is not just a business model. Policies should map and prioritize monetary, healthcare, food and psycho-social support for educators. During the pandemic, it has also been seen that administrative load on teachers has increased due to cost-cutting. (6/6)#BackToSchool
— Nalini Ravichandran (@naliniravi9) September 5, 2020
She added that in addition to equipping teachers with digital resources, there is also a need to bridge the access gap for students, particularly girls. As teachers from the panel shared, both students and teachers need to be equipped with and trained in using technology to facilitate continued education in the age of digital education.
डिजिटल एजुकेशन अपने आप में ही एक चुनौती है।
सबसे बढ़ी समस्या 60% अभिभावकों के पास एंड्रॉयड फोंन का आभाव है।
पढ़े-लिखे लोग भी सीधा साफ़ कहते हैं हमें अपने बच्चों को नहीं देना ऑनलाइन एजुकेशन आप चाहे कुछ भी कहें।
कई दफ़े माता-पिता या बच्चे ही हमें ब्लॉक कर चुके हैं।— Shirsti Tiwari (@shirsti_tiwari) September 5, 2020
कोविड ने शिक्षा को प्रभावित किया है। ग्रामीण क्षेत्रों में बच्चों के पास इंटरनेट की सुविधा भी उपलब्ध नहीं है जिस कारण उनको ऑनलाइन स्टडी से जोड़ पाना भी बेहद मुश्किल भरा रहा। जिन बच्चों के पास नेट की उपलब्धता भी रही तो वे उसके उपयोग से पूर्णतया अनभिज्ञ थे।
— Ankur Tripathi (@ankur_vimukt) September 5, 2020
This critical conversation was organised in partnership with Malala Fund. During this conversation, experts, educators, and young people came to the fore and engaged with one another to spark a conversation around the challenges of digital education teachers are facing during the pandemic and how teachers play a critical role in bringing children #BackToSchool and form a major part of the support system for children, especially girls, in being able to pursue their education.